An Accident When a Friend Uses Your Car. Who Pays?

Allen Ritchie • July 19, 2024

Question: I loaned my car to a friend. In a wreck, do I have to pay?

JASON: It might surprise you, but the state of Alabama says you have given a dangerous instrument to another person. Therefore, you can be held responsible if something terrible happens. This is no different than if you gave a person a gun, a bomb, or anything else that could be used to hurt someone.

Now, before you grab back your keys or hide your F-150, know that insurance plays a big part. In Alabama, car insurance follows the car. If you have state-mandated insurance, your insurance will pay for injuries to the driver and passengers that your friend hit. It will also pay for the damage to their car. If you have additional insurance, it can cover your friend’s injuries and repairs to your car.

If your friend has insurance, it may kick in, but only after your insurance has maxed out. Of course, your friend can pay for everything out of their own pocket. But let’s face it—your friend borrowed your car, so he or she probably doesn’t have a lot of cash.

A good lawyer can do many things to help. I have been able to use insurance policies the car owner had on other cars to pay expenses. I have even gotten homeowners insurance to help pay, but this is tricky and depends on your circumstances.

Let me mention another thing Alabama takes very seriously. If you loan your car to someone you know shouldn’t drive, you could face a variety of legal problems. Some examples include knowing of the driver’s drinking problems, a history of reckless driving by the borrower, mental issues that made the driver unreliable, and knowing your friend does not have a valid license.

Here is another question I am often asked: Do I have to be present when the accident occurs for my insurance to be responsible? No.

In summary, when someone borrows your car, they are borrowing your insurance. Loan both wisely.

Car wrecks in and around Mobile and Baldwin Counties seem to be on the increase. If you have concerns, don’t hesitate to call us. The call will cost you nothing. My advice is to act quickly. As time passes, evidence can easily disappear, and witnesses can become more difficult to locate.

Jason Steele

Personal Injury Attorney in Mobile, AL

 

Talk to me for free  (251) 666-1212

Contact Us Today for a Free Consultation

A termite is crawling on a rock in the water.
By Steele Ritchie June 20, 2025
Termite Damage in Alabama: What You Need to Know (Q&A)
A judge 's gavel is sitting on top of a black table.
By Jason Steele March 28, 2025
Injured? Why a limited amount of time to sue in Alabama? Learn more from Jason Steele from Steele Ritchie LLC.
A man is writing on a piece of paper with a pen.
By Allen A. Ritchie March 21, 2025
Live In Alabama? 3 Essential Legal Papers … or Regret It Later. Learn more from Allen Ritchie with Steele Ritchie LLC.
A woman is sitting on a window sill with her head in her hands.
By Jason Steele March 17, 2025
Injured, Do I Have to Hand Over My Clothes? Learn more with Jason Steele from Steele Ritchie LLC.
A bunch of termites are crawling on a wooden surface.
By Allen Ritchie March 7, 2025
You cannot live in the Mobile area and not know about termites. Every year, they come, and they stay here all year long. Why? They like what we like – our warm summers and mild winters. In fact, the area around here is perfect … and I mean perfect … for termites. Those dangerous, destructive […] The post Termites Coming to Mobile and Baldwin Counties first appeared on Steele Ritchie.
A woman is driving a car on a highway.
By Allen Ritchie March 3, 2025
Question: An Uber or Lyft accident. Is it like being a passenger in a friend’s car? JASON: Not in Alabama. Plus, getting you paid can be complex, and you may need a lawyer to figure it out. Here is the big difference: You are dealing with a business, not an individual. The good news is […] The post Suing the Uber Driver After a Wreck first appeared on Steele Ritchie.
A woman is laying on a couch blowing her nose with a napkin.
By Allen Ritchie February 21, 2025
Here, in and around Mobile, we can work in some dangerous situations and with some very dangerous chemicals. Not feeling well? Don’t think your illness is just part of getting older. It could be that your job is literally killing you. This happens more often than most people think. In Alabama, it is estimated that […] The post AL Law: Work Is Making Me Sick first appeared on Steele Ritchie.
A young girl in a purple jacket is sitting on a couch with her hands on her chin.
By Allen Ritchie February 17, 2025
Question: If a Moon Pie injures me, can I sue? JASON: Really, you want to tell a jury in Mobile that a pastry hurt you? Well, happy Mardi Gras. Seriously, the question is not, can you sue, but rather, can you win? I am going to guess that you were hit by a Moon Pie […] The post Injured by Moon Pie. Can I Sue? first appeared on Steele Ritchie.
Two cars are involved in a car accident on the side of the road.
By Steele Ritchie February 11, 2025
A personal injury accident can be overwhelming, leaving victims confused and unsure of what steps to take next. Knowing the proper actions to take immediately after the accident can significantly affect your recovery and legal claim, whether it’s a car accident, slip and fall, workplace injury, or another type of incident. Taking swift action helps […] The post What to Do After a Personal Injury Accident: A Step-by-Step Guide first appeared on Steele Ritchie.
A person is holding a cell phone with social media icons on the screen.
By Allen Ritchie February 7, 2025
After an accident, not only can your family and friends read your posts – but so can the other driver’s insurance company. And those guys are looking for any reason not to pay you. Posting about your accident could cost you thousands of dollars. Yes, thousands. Here are 5 tips I share with my clients: […] The post Stop the Social Media. You’re Injuring Your Injury Case. first appeared on Steele Ritchie.
Show More